Some time ago an old college friend who had gone on to be an English professor admitted that he not only did not enjoy the poetry of T.S.Eliot, but he didn’t have the faintest clue what Eliot was about.

I had been a fan of Eliot for a long time and asked what the problem was. “The poetry is totally fragmented. Nothing is connected. It seems like no more than a collection of images.”

My friend was right about the “collection of images.” In re-reading Eliot’s groundbreaking The Waste Land and  The Hollow Men we are indeed confronted by “a heap of broken images. The images are auditory, visual, musical, literary and historical. 

Here a quote from Shakespeare, Dante, the Old Testament or the Bhagavad Gita—there a snippet from a popular ragtime song or a Wagnerian opera. Here a reference to Frazer or Arthurian legend only to be brought up short with a vulgar conversation in a London pub between two cockney women. The visual images conjure up a bleak Parisian or London cityscape of the late 1920s: the poet sees a discarded waste bobbing in the Thames: “empty bottles, sandwich papers,/ Silk handkerchiefs, cardboard boxes.” There are rat infested alleyways, lonely slatterns and carbuncular clerks, crowds of shuffling commuters and the melancholy bells of city churches. The images are mingled with the nightmarish memories of Eliot’s own horrific marriage to a hysterical, unfaithful imbalanced young dancer.

What does it all mean and how does one make sense of Eliot’s wasteland of broken images? To start the reader needs to put the poem into context. In 1921—at the time of writing, Europe had just emerged from the devastating First World War. Eliot was trapped in England, impoverished, separated from his family and locked in a hasty and disastrous marriage. Taking a break from his stressful work as a bank clerk and literary editor, Eliot moved first to Margate in Kent, then to a clinic in Switzerland to be treated for his disintegrating mental and emotional health.

In a fascinating article on the influences on Eliot, David Barnes of Trinity College, Oxford explored the treatment Eliot received for his nervous exhaustion. Eliot was being treated by Roger Vittoz, the author of Treatment of Neurasthenia by Means of Brain Control. Vittoz’s unique methodology consisted of various exercises through which the patient was expected to concentrate on particular objects, images or repeated sounds in order to gain and retain control over a mind that was buzzing with chaotic and obsessive memories, thoughts and emotions. 

Eliot’s busy brain was working overtime with a whirl of worries, emotional obligations, guilt, work pressures and stresses from repressed emotions and fractured relationships. Vittoz’s therapy helped him order his mind and by ordering the fractured images, to regain control of his emotions. As the whirling broken images came into focus during his time in Switzerland Eliot was able to compose The Waste Land. Eliot admitted later that the poem was composed when he was in a troubled state of mind and dismissed the poem as ““the relief of a personal and wholly insignificant grouse against life,” a “piece of rhythmical grumbling.”

Be that as it may, The Waste Land continues to resonate because Eliot’s “heap of broken images” so sharply reflects the state of Western culture—a condition far more broken now a century later than Eliot’s world of the 1920s. 

Dr Vittoz’s therapy helped to order the poet’s mind, but the other factor which helps the reader make sense of the heap of broken images is Eliot’s understanding of the poetic use of images. From the French symbolist poets Eliot took the idea of the “objective correlative”. According to the theory, an evocative image is presented not for its concrete meaning or its denotative sense, but for the emotion it evokes.

Let us say the image is “Come in under the shadow of this red rock and I will show you…fear in a handful of dust.” The image seems inexplicable. What is the red rock? Why the shadow and why a handful of dust? 

The question is not “What does it mean?” But “How does it make you feel?”. Connections are made with allusions in the mind. What is red but the color of blood and what is the shadow of a rock but the valley of the shadow of death? And what is a handful of dust except the echo of the ominous incantation of Ash Wednesday: “Remember you are dust and to dust you shall return?” Then the mourners traditionally take a handful of dust to scatter on your coffin. What do you feel? It is uncertainty and fear.

So with Eliot “You cannot say, or guess, for you know only A heap of broken images, where the sun beats and the dead tree gives no shelter.” 

It seems like a counsel of despair. Nevertheless, we know Eliot was already turning from the Waste Land to the Fertile Land of Faith. Eliot’s biographers record that the original manuscript of Eliot’s masterpiece had much more positive Christian content and emphasis, but this was was purged by Ezra Pound’s heavy handed editing.  

Despite Pound’s hacking, Eliot does not leave us in the dark. By the end of the poem the poet finds order and peace. He chants the words from the Upanishads, “Datta, Dayadhvam, Damyata,—Give, Sympathise, Control.” So he is able to conclude about the heap of broken images, “These fragments I have shored against my ruin.”