A Utah judge has ruled against a legal ban on polygamy.
Mark Gordon reports on the case here. The story is not that complicated. Kody Brown, who is a member of a fundamentalist Mormon sect is living with his four wives. The judge observes that if they were not married, but just living together in an adulterous relationship the law would have nothing to say about the situation. They’re only being prosecuted because they claim to be married, but it is impossible for the man to have more than one marriage license so, although they say they are married, in the eyes of the law they’re just living together and that’s not a crime.
In other words, if you call it polyamory and not polygamy it’s okay. Live with as many women as you like and “marry” them in your church if that pleases you, just don’t expect legal recognition of the multiple marriages.
But surely that will be challenged in the courts. Same sex couples were permitted to live together as husband and wife and nobody said “Boo” but they insisted on legal recognition of their “marriages”. Shouldn’t polygamous couples have the same right? Isn’t it unfair for three of Kody’s wives to not have legal recognition, protection under the law, insurance benefits and other privileges that spouses enjoy?
Furthermore, the arguments for polygamy are rather impressive. Those in favor would say, “This strengthens the family unit. Children have four mommies and therefore they all have more loving attention and care. Economically the family unit is stronger because there could be multiple earners. With the breakdown of the traditional extended family, large family units with multiple wives give a strong, secure and loving environment. It is difficult for one woman to be a good home maker, an extra earner, the perfect mom, a great cook, a loving companion and a perfect wife. The polygamous family allows a woman to specialize. One is a good cook, another is a good lover, another is great with child care, another is an extra earner, another is artsy and creative, who are we to judge? These seem like nice people with good family values. They are religious and are training their children in a strong, loving, happy family to have good, respectful, traditional values. Furthermore, this is a matter of their religious freedom rights. They are entitled to practice their religion freely–even if it is unusual–like the Amish, the Muslims or any other religious minority.”
How can anyone argue against that?
The underlying problem is with the argumentation. In the paragraph above I have used three types of argument: utilitarian, sentimental, and civil rights. Increasingly in cases of law and legislation these three arguments are the only ones that are used.
Utilitarian is “what works is good”. The case is made that this or that lifestyle is okay because it has advantages. There doesn’t seem to be any harm done, and if the people choose that lifestyle, and if it works for them, then it is okay. The sentimental argument says, “Aww gee. Look at those nice folks. They mean well and they’re awfully good neighbors. Why should we be so mean and say what they’re doing is wrong?” The civil rights argument is the one that says that everyone pretty much has the freedom to do as they please as long as they harm no one.
There is no problem with making these three forms of argument, but there is a problem when these are the only forms of argument, and they have become the only forms of argument because of a deeper underlying problem in our society. This is the problem of relativism. If there is no objective natural law, and if there is no divine law giver, then these three forms of argument really are the only ones, and the person who wins the argument is the one who shows that a particular lifestyle choice works best, that the people are nice and that they should have the right to do what they want.
In other words, “If an idea works, its okay. If the people seem nice and kind who are we to judge? They have the right to do as they wish. This is America. We love our freedom!”
It doesn’t take a genius to figure out that if these three arguments are all you have, then the gas chambers are only a short jump away.
Why? Because eliminating millions of undesirables is an idea that works. If it is done by nice professional, polite people then that makes it seem okay, and why should those who want to create a utopia not have the right to follow their beliefs?
You will say that the gas chambers harm others, but history has shown that if those “others” are deemed to be sub human then it doesn’t matter. The Jews, Gypsies, Jehovah’s Witnesses, homosexuals and Communists were simply inferior–like the mentally retarded, disabled and insane who were the first ones to be weeded out. If those to be eliminated are also dangerous to the state and the security of others it is arguable that they should be first imprisoned and then eliminated.
The Federal judge in this case (and other current cases on similar matters show his opinions to be prevalent) is not so much opening the door to polygamy as he is admitting that American legal decisions are now based only on the unholy trinity of utilitarianism, sentimentality and civil rights. This is not so much a further erosion of the idea of Christian marriage (which is a cornerstone of a Christian civilization) as it is an attack on the whole idea of an objective law that is the foundation for civil law.
American legislative decisions are now decided according to utilitarianism, sentimentalism and civil rights. Therefore it is only a matter of time before the logic is followed and the ideologues start weeding the garden.