The Bishop was present in the parish over the weekend to celebrate the sacrament of confirmation, and after sharing dinner with him and the Holy Deacon I was pondering the immensity of his task. The Catholic Church is so amazingly diverse, and the bishop is the focus of unity for the diocese. How does he do it?

Considering the clergy alone he has to deal with secular clergy and religious, priests from Africa, Asia, South and Central America. Many of them have English as a second language and struggle to minister in a foreign land. Then he has to deal with aging priests, a few married convert priests and young priests still wet behind the ears. Added to this diversity are differences of opinion regarding liturgy, theology and priorities in the church.

Diversity in the church is a rich blessing, but division in the church terrible curse. There is acceptable diversity in cultural expressions of worship and different styles of worship, but there is no room for ‘diversity’ when it comes to the teaching of the Catholic Church–and this is where modernists stumble and betray the faith. They mistake proper diversity of style and culture with dissent on crucial matters of faith. So they will maintain that it is okay that they disagree with the church on artificial contraception, women’s ordination, same sex ‘marriage’ or abortion. “This is all part of the “diversity” we celebrate in the church.” they claim.

There are indeed some matters of church teaching and devotion which remain provisional or are only “pious opinion.” The Blessed Mother has not been defined as Co-Redeemer. You don’t have to wear the brown scapular if you don’t want to. Devotion to the Sacred Heart of Jesus is optional and women don’t have to wear hats to church. There are many practices and principles that are up for grabs, but the heart of church teaching is not, and when we treat as optional the truths that are defined and defended as de fide  we are on the path of division and dissent–not simple diversity.

The most subtle form of this division and dissent is when a Catholic emphasizes a legitimate aspect of church life over and above the core mission of the church. Put it like this: the basic mission of the church is to be the Body of Christ on earth. She does what Christ did, and these are four things: 1. Teach the Truth 2. Heal the Sick 3. Forgive Sins 4. Take authority over evil. The basic mission of the church is therefore to bring Christ’s redemption to a needy world–in other words–to save souls.

When we put anything else before this fundamental mission division is the result.

 

 

The things we put before it may be very good. They may be part of the legitimate results of the church’s primary mission, but when they are put first division is the result–not unity. Here is an example: ministry to the poor and needy is a secondary part of the church’s mission. It is the result of the first priority being done properly. That is to say, once we have saved souls those redeemed individuals want to minister to the world in the compassionate mercy of Christ–whose Spirit fills them. Educating children, celebrating and preserving distinct cultures, preserving the environment, encouraging art and music, architecture and literature–all these worthy things are the secondary mission of the church. They are the fruit and result of the primary mission of the church.

When we put them first however, division results because these secondary missions become pet causes. They divert the energies and expenditure and enthusiasm away from the primary mission of the church which brings unity. Furthermore, a focus on the secondary missions of the church eventually destroy the church itself. Why? Because people are not stupid. They soon figure out that you can do those secondary aspects of mission without the bother of going to church at all.

If the most important thing is building schools for poor children, fostering wonderful art or architecture, feeding the hungry and helping the down and out, then why bother with  all that liturgy, worship, prayer and salvation of souls stuff? People draw the conclusion that you can be good and foster fine art, community building and helping the needy without all that religion. So they stop practicing their religion.

I am convinced from conversations with lapsed Catholics that this is exactly what they think. I know this because they say, “You can be good without going to church.” or “I am spiritual but not religious” or “I’m just as good as the people who go to church.”

This is the result of the implicit Pelagianism of our times. When priests focus all their ministry on serving the poor rather than saving the poor the Catholic faith is ultimately undermined. When church people focus completely on the good works of their religion rather than religion itself, their religion will eventually crumble into nothing.

The unity we enjoy in the Catholic faith, and the unity which the bishop represents is the unity we share in the cross of Christ. It is within that mystery that we glory. It is that mystery we proclaim as we preach Christ crucified. It is that mystery we celebrate at the holy sacrifice of the altar.

The rest is secondary.