One of the details was the authorship of the Book of Abraham–one of the books in the Mormon scriptures. It’s a fascinating story. In 1830 or thereabouts a traveling sideshow entrepreneur turned up at Joseph Smith’s fledgling Mormon community in Ohio and sold Smith some Egyptian mummies and a couple of papyrus manuscripts. Smith proceeded to ‘translate’ the manuscripts and told his people they were none other than the stories of the patriarchs Abraham and Joseph from their sojourn in Egypt, and they were actually written in the very hand of Abraham and Joseph themselves. Smith went on to translate the scrolls and add them to the Mormon scriptures.

Time went on and Smith ended up being murdered by a mob in Illinois, and his estranged wife sold the mummies to a museum in Chicago where they were destroyed in a fire and everybody thought the manuscripts were destroyed too. But they turned up in 1966. By now the scholarship of ancient Egypt had advanced (thanks to the Rosetta Stone) so Smith’s translation of the manuscripts could be checked. Turns out they were just some pretty standard Egyptian burial documents.

Smith’s story was totally and completely and breathtakingly bogus.

You can learn all about this in detail by watching the interesting video here.

None of this surprises me too much, but the comments I received from Mormons are what I found most intriguing.

…I was prepared for some folks to defend the Book of Abraham, saying that there were other parts of the original manuscript which were indeed lost, or proposing that there were still questions to be answered and the that we had to wait to make a judgement until all the scholars finished their work or some such.

However, what did surprise me were the comments along these lines: “Since some books of the Bible are written under someone else’s name the actual historical veracity of the Book of Abraham is irrelevant. What matters is whether the theology of the book is true.” Another person said, “You don’t really believe that Abraham was a historical character do you? The whole Abraham saga is to be understood as a mythic-heroic tale.” Still others implied that the Mormon scriptures, the history of Smith and Brigham Young and the historicity of the scriptures were all secondary to the “fruit in the lives of Mormons”. In other words, “All that book stuff doesn’t matter. We have a religion that makes people happy!”

What I was experiencing was what can only be called Modernistic Mormonism. We are well used to this phenomenon in the mainstream Christian churches. The modernist scholars de-bunk the historicity of the Scriptures, dismantle the history of the church and deny the supernatural element of the New Testament. They are left with a religion of doing good in the world, being nice to people, being political activists and raising money for good causes. The Scriptures are reduced to a source book for inspiring messages and homely feel good chats about being wonderful. I have become quite used to this sickly form of religion in Christianity.

I was surprised to discover the Mormons had their own version. For the Mormons–who have a history that is dubious–are probably well served by scholars who tell them that the history didn’t really matter, the facts don’t matter and the actual veracity of their Scriptures and their origins are inconsequential.

As for the Catholic faith…well you’ll forgive me if I want to check the facts. If the incarnation of the Son of God didn’t really happen amongst the Jews in what is now Palestine 2,000 years ago, and if he didn’t die a criminal’s death and rise again…if it didn’t happen then I’m outa here.

If I want a made up religion about positive thinking, being nice, good orthodontics and starting a soup kitchen, I’ll make up my own.

Why not? Making up your own religion seems like one of America’s most successful enterprises.

UPDATE: Over here Mark Shea deals with a Catholic modernist who has the same ‘who cares if it really happened’ attitude to the resurrection of Jesus Christ