The horrible thing about the film is that the aliens are not huge hybrid insectoid lobster monsters, but just as ordinary as the guy and girl next door.

This image came to me when contemplating the kind of heretics we experience in the church today. I recently finished Dr Marcellino D’Ambrosio’s When the Church Was Young (which is an excellent, readable study of the fathers of the church) The value of his book is that he not only discusses the formal heresies of the day and what they meant theologically, but he also explains the cultural milieu of the time.

What interested me about the Arian controversy was that Arianism was the preferred heresy of the elite.

As a reminder, the formal Arian heresy was the belief that Jesus Christ was not God incarnate, but a created being.

This was held by the leading bishops of the day, the emperor and his mother and all the top people of the church and state. In other words, it was held by the respectable people. It was the sort of religion you would make up if you were making up a religion. It played down the stupendous and the supernatural in favor of a “believable” Christianity–a religion of good works, being nice and making the world a better place.

Do you see where I’m going with this? Arianism is rife in our church today. The only difference is that the present day Arians don’t declare their heresy formally for the most part. If you dig into the theological writings of the liberal Christians you’ll find that they do in fact deny the incarnation, but they do so in a sneaky way with circumlocution and silence on certain matters that speaks volumes.

Most of all are the Arians in disguise. These are the liberal priests, bishops and theologians who trot about in their finery being all respectable and using all the language of historic Christianity while they don’t really believe it. 

 

They call this “re-interpretation”. They will recite the Nicene Creed with a pompous voice, “God from God, Light from Light, Very God of Very God, Consubstantial with the Father” but when they are pressed they will smile and say, “Jesus Christ was surely the best man who ever lived. So good, in fact, that he reveals to us what God is like.”

These folks are like the victims of the body snatchers. They look just like the Christian next door, but they are aliens and Arians.

How to sniff them out? I reckon they’re the ones who are respectable just as they were in the fourth century. They hold secure and comfortable chairs of theology in academia. They have money. They have prestige. They have political places. They have climbed the greasy pole in the church. They sit comfortably in this world and follow a religion that is watered down, with the supernatural power of God and the scandalous belief in the Incarnation conveniently excised.

Give me Athanasius instead. Persecuted, exiled, scorned and mocked for his tenacious adherence to the true faith, he fought the Arians and eventually prevailed.

The same struggle continues in the church today with those who would make Christianity easy and comfortable, for those who would tear down the true faith and substitute a “sensible and believable” alternative.

Let truth be told: Comfortable Catholicism and Cafeteria Catholicism will die out.

Because comfortable Catholicism aka Arianism is not strong enough to endure persecution. If they gave up the true faith for a comfy job, respectable friends and a good career path does anyone imagine they will stand up and be counted when  trouble comes?