I complained to him one day that when I was a theology student I lived by faith. I really had no money and was living from hand to mouth with the little I could earn while I studied.

Now that I had a job and a house and a salary it seemed boring.

So he said, “Why don’t you give half of your money away? That will make it interesting.”

I said, “Okay. Let’s do it.”

“By the way,” he said, “I think we’re also going to have lots of other people come to live here.”

I started giving half my money away and we lived on the rest and he was right. Within the year my apartment was filled with about six other guys living with us in an informal kind of religious community. We prayed together and did church work. When they got part time jobs they contributed to our financial needs.

I didn’t tell anyone I was giving away half my salary and that what I had left (and there wasn’t much to start with) had to provide for eight of us.

To help feed everyone my brother would get up early and bake two loaves of bread.

He went to the local bakery and bought a big 50 lb. bag of flour.

This was in June. The baker estimated that if my brother baked two loaves a day the flour would last until September. We had to use it up by then because if we didn’t it would get weevils.

We needed more bread and my brother started baking three or even four loaves a day.

That was good bread.

In December we noticed that the flour had not been used up. It lasted three months longer than it should have and it didn’t have weevils.

In December one of the guys got a good job and we could afford to buy flour as we needed it.

Did we experience a multiplication of food similar to the one with Elijah and the widow woman?

I believe we did, and that’s one of the reasons why I believe in miracles.

That’s also why you should not buy into any preacher who holds forth on the feeding of the 5,000 saying “the real miracle was that they all shared their lunch”

That is so lame.

That’s baloney. Either it was a miracle or the gospel is a lie.

For other miracles of multiplication of food check out some of the stories about Fr Solanus Casey and check out the now dated, but still fascinating 1981 video from Catholic Charismatic Services of American Catholics–members of a parish in New Mexico who went to take Christmas dinner to Mexicans…and experienced a multiplication of food. The video is called Viva Christo Rey.

Did I really experience a miraculous multiplication of food? We have to think it through a little

Whenever we are confronted with claims of the supernatural the church teaches us to take a middle way between total skepticism and total gulliblility.

No, that bagel that you think has the face of Mother Teresa in it is not a miracle. Thats something called Pareidolia. It’s a natural psychological phenomenon.

Evil is not always caused by demons. There is often a perfectly natural explanation.

So it is with miracles. We’re advised to always look for the natural explanation first. Only when the natural explanations fail us do we begin to grant that the supernatural is involved.

However, while we are supposed to be cautious we are not supposed to rule miracles out altogether. A miracle is, by definition, a suspension or an exception to the usually expected natural laws.

Was our bread flour miraculously multiplied? It’s possible, but there were enough variables and other possibilities that we can’t say for sure. It could be that the baker estimated incorrectly how many loaves we would be able to bake. It could be that the loaves were smaller than he anticipated. Maybe we didn’t end up making as much bread as we thought we were. There are too many other options to allow me to shout from the housetops that a real miracle occurred.

I therefore shrug my shoulders and say, “Well, I believe it was a miracle, and thank God!” As soon as I say that other troubling thoughts come to mind. If it was a miracle why did it suddenly stop? If God provided flour for our bread for a few months why doesn’t he do miracles and stop famines from happening? Why do little children still starve?

At the end of the day a miracle is, by definition, something which defies not only our expectations but our logic. Miracles are outside the realm of human logic alone. They are part of a bigger and stranger plan that we cannot see. That plan and that realm operates with a logic that is beyond our logic and a reasoning that is stranger and greater than our own.

I’ve written a fair bit about miracles on my blog. Go here to read a post about people who were seeing the Virgin Mary in a tree trunk in New Jersey.

Here is a longer piece asking whether miracles are possible or not. This post recounts a miraculous delivery from death in a car accident and discusses the mystery of miracles.

Here’s the story of St Thomas Aquinas and the nun who could levitate and here is my archived article about unexplained phenomenon called Weird Things Happen